Marker Based Standardization
of Novel Herbal Dental Gel
N.M. Momin1, J.I. Disouza1, P.A.
Tatke2, Melita Gonsalves2 and Aparna M.2
1Tatyasaheb Kore
College of Pharmacy, Warananagar, Kolhapur
2C.U. Shah College of Pharmacy, S.N.D.T.
University, Santacruz (W), Mumbai- 400049
*Corresponding Author E-mail: nilofar.momin@rediffmail.com
ABSTRACT
Standardization is a burning
topic in Ayurvedic drug industry today. Tremendous work is going on herbal drug standardization.
One of the important methods
for standardization of herbal drugs is marker based standardization. It helps
in adjusting the herbal drug formulation to a defined content of constituent/s with therapeutic activity. A chemically
defined constituent of herbal drug, which is used for quality control and
assurance of finished product, is known as Marker compound.
Acacia nilotica Linn. (family- Leguminosae), commonly known as “Babul”, is a plant
mentioned in Ayurveda for maintainence
of oral hygiene. Traditionally tender
twigs of Acacia nilotica Linn. have been used
as ‘datun’ for cleansing of teeth. It is one of the
ingredients of many marketed dental formulations such as toothpowders and
toothpastes. Catechin being a major constituent of Acacia nilotica can be used as a marker for standardization of
herbal dental gel containing Acacia nilotica.
KEYWORDS: Standardization, Catechin,
Acacia nilotica, HPTLC
1. INTRODUCTION:
In recent years, there is a spurt in the interest
regarding survival of Ayurvedic forms of medication. In the global perspective,
there is a shift towards the use of medicine of herbal origin, as the dangers
and the shortcomings of modern medicine have started getting more apparent.
Majority of Ayurvedic formulations are prepared from the plants. Unfortunately,
the Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia and the formulary have been exempted from the
standards attained by present day modern medicine which is continuously
undergoing metamorphic changes and improvements in the standards of purity,
safety and efficacy. Thus, maintaining the quality of Ayurvedic medications
becomes the sole responsibility of the manufacturer7.
The Food and Drug Administration in India
does not have the same stringent rules for quality of Ayurvedic preparations as
they have for the quality of raw materials and finished products of allopathic
drugs.
Though it is difficult to give a precise
method of standardization, with the use of the modern analytical techniques
available, it should be still possible to evolve some simple methods of quality
control and identification of crude drugs. Traditional pharmacognostic
work on indigenous medical plants is available but generally it is out of reach
of Ayurvedic drug manufacturers. Certain efforts in this direction will assure
the consumers the quality of the product and thus its efficacy8.
There is a great demand for herbal
medicines in the developed as well as developing countries because of their
wide biological activities, higher safety margin than the synthetic drugs and
lesser costs. Since herbal medicines are prepared from materials of plant
origin they are prone to contamination, deterioration and variation in
composition. This gives rise to inferior quality of herbal products with little
or no therapeutic efficacy. Most often the desired biological response is due
to not one but a mixture of bioactive constituents and the relative proportion
of active constituents can vary from plant to plant of the same species and
also in different plant parts.
The World Heath
Organization has recognized the importance of traditional medicines and has
created strategies, guidelines and standards for botanical medicines. Proven
agro-industrial technologies need to be applied to the cultivation and
processing of medicinal plants and the manufacture of herbal medicines.
It
is necessary to develop methods for rapid precise and accurate identification
and estimation of active constituents in order to bring out consistency of
important constituents in the formulations. This is especially true for export oriented products
as the western countries have stringent quality control parameters. Most of the
tests described in ancient texts however are based on observation and are
subjective. Hence, it is essential to find out modern correlates of Ayurvedic
quality control tests.
With the use of
modern methods of analysis such as TLC, HPTLC, HPLC etc. it is possible to set
up certain standards for analysis of a particular constituent from the
Ayurvedic formulations.
One of the important methods of standardization of
herbal drugs is isolation of Marker compounds from plants and standardization
of herbal formulations with isolated markers.
2. Experimental:
2.1 Materials:
Standard catechin
was supplied as a gift sample by UICT, Mumbai. All the solvents used for the analytical work were of
Analytical grade (AR). The TLC and HPTLC studies were done using precoated TLC plates of Silica gel 60 GF254 (Merck).
HPTLC studies were carried out using CAMAG LINOMAT IV applicator and CAMAG
SCANNER III with WINCATS III software. All chemicals and reagents used are of HPLC and
AR grade supplied by Merk Ltd.
3. Methodology:
3.1 Preparation of Acacia nilotica
gel:
Bark of Acacia nilotica was procured frm local
market Mumbai and authenticated by Piramal Life
Sciences, Mumbai. Bark was dried and powdered for further processings.
Dried, powdered bark of Acacia nilotica Linn. was extracted with acetone for 18 hours
using Soxlet extraction apparatus. The extract was
concentrated under vacuum and the color, nature and percent extractive values
(w/w) with respect to dry powder were
determined.
Acetone extract at a
concentration of 10% w/w was triturated to form a fine non- gritty powder and
uniformly dispersed in glycerine. This was then
incorporated into an aqueous gel base using Carbopol
as gelling agent at 0.5, 1 and 1.5% w/w concentrations. 10% NaOH
was used as neutralizing agent.
The gel was evaluated for
parameters like organoleptic properties, pH, spreadability, Stability studies were conducted at
refrigeration and room temperatures. Accelerated stability studies were done as
per ICH guidelines. Samples of the gel were evaluated for parameters like
color, pH, extract content, spreadability and
antimicrobial activity
3.2 HPTLC method development:
HPTLC method was developed
for catechin. Standard catechin
was dissolved in Methanol .Sttandard solution of
Concentration (0.5 µg/μl) was prepared and
spotted on TLC plate using LINOMAT IV applicator and CAMAG SCANNER III. Samples
were spotted on precoated plates and the plates were
the scanned at 278 nm which was the reported λmax
for Catechin.The mobile phase used was toluene: ethyl
acetate: methanol: formic acid (6: 6:1:0.1) as amobile
phase.
Densitometric conditions:
Stationary phase :
Silica gel 60 GF254 (Merck)
Saturation time :
30 min.
Development time :15
min.
Band width :
7 mm
Wavelength
: 278 nm
Lamp : Deuterium
3.3 HPTLC method validation:
The developed method was
validated as per the ICH guidelines. The following parameters are validated.
3.3.1 Accuracy:
Accuracy may often be expressed as percent
recovery by the assay of known, added amounts of analyte.
It is a measure of the exactness of the analytical method.
The accuracy of developed HPTLC method was determined by applying that method to samples to which
known amounts of analyte have been added. The accuracy
is then calculated from the test results as the percentage of analyte recovered by the assay. The known amount of standard catechin was added to the preanalyzed
samples and was subjected to HPTLC
study. At each level of recovery three determination were carried out
3.3.2 Precision:
The method was validated for precision by
repeatability: Repeatability is
obtained when the analysis is carried out in one laboratory by one operator
using one piece of equipment over a relatively short time span. At least
·
5 or 6
determinations of
·
three
different matrices at
·
two or
three different concentrations
Should be done and the relative standard deviation
calculated. The acceptance criteria for precision depend very much on the type
of analysis. While for compound analysis in pharmaceutical quality control
precision of better than 1 % RSD is easily achieved
The concentration selected for repeatability studies
were 0.1 μg, 0.3 μg and 0.5 μg of Catechin.
3.3.3 Linearity and Range:
The linearity of an analytical method is its
ability to elicit test results that are directly, or by a well defined
mathematical transformation, proportional to the concentration of analyte in samples within a given range. Linearity is
usually expressed in terms of the variance around the slope of the regression
line calculated according to an established mathematical relationship from test
results obtained by the analysis of samples with varying concentrations of analyte.
Standards: The coefficient of correlation
should be more than 0.995
3.3.4 Limit of detection :
The limit of detection is the lowest concentration of analyte in a sample that can be detected, but not
necessarily quantitated, under the stated
experimental conditions. The limit of detection is usually expressed as the
concentration of analyte in the sample.
In chromatography the detection limit is the injected
amount that results in a peak with a height at least twice or three times as
high as the baseline noise level. The
limit of detection and limit of quantitation were
determined based on calibration curves.
3.3.5 Limit of Quantitation:
Limit of Quantitation
is a parameter of quantitative assay for low levels of compounds in ample
matrices, such as impurities in bulk drug substances and degradation products
in finished pharmaceuticals. It is the lowest concentration of analyte in a sample that can be determined with acceptable
precision and accuracy under the stated experimental conditions. The limit of Quantitation is expressed as the concentration of analyte in the sample.
The limit of Quantitation
is the minimum injected amount that gives precise measurements, in
chromatography typically requiring peak heights 20 times higher than baseline
noise or 3 times the detection limit.
3.3.6 Robustmess:
The robustness of the method
was studied and during this small
changes were made in composition of mobile phase and effects of this were
observed on the chromatographic behavior of the sample. The effects of
following parameters were observed, Rf value, peak
area, the various mobile phases used were,
1. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic
acid (6: 6:0.5:1)
2. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic
acid (5: 7:1:1)
3. Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic
acid (7: 5:0.5:1)
3.4 Standardization of Acacia nilotica
gel:
The methanol extract of Acacia nilotica gel was prepared with
concentration of 100 mg/ml.Samples were spotted on precoated plates and the plates were the scanned at 278 nm which
was the reported λmax for Catechin.
The mobile phase used was toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (6:
6:1:0.1) as a mobile phase.
Densitometric conditions:
Stationary phase : Silica gel 60 GF254 (Merck)
Mobile phase :
Toluene: ethyl acetate: methanol: formic acid (6: 6:1:0.1)
Saturation time : 30 min
Development time : 15 min
Band width
: 7 mm
Wavelength
: 278 nm
Lamp
: Deuterium
4.
Result and Discussion:
4.1 HPTLC method development:
The HPTLC method was
successfully developed for Catechin. Catechin was found to be linear in the range 500-3000ng.
The Coefficeint of Correlation was found to be 0.998
Figure
No. 1 Calibration curve for Catechin
Figure
2: HPTLC fingerprint for standard Catechin at 278 nm
Figure
3: HPTLC fingerprint of methanolic extract of 100 μg
of Acacia nilotica
gel.
4.2 Standardization of Acacia nilotica
gel :
With the
developed HPTLC method Acacia nilotica gel was analysed.
It contains mainly Catechin as major constituent. The
% content of catechin in Acacia nilotica gel
was determined from the standard plot of Catechin.
The % content of catechin in Acacia nilotica gel was calculated from equation.
Table No: 1
Linearity studies of Catechin
|
Sr. No. |
Concentration of catechin |
Area Under Curve |
|
1. |
0.5 μg |
1407.1 |
|
2. |
1 μg |
2079.2 |
|
3. |
1.5 μg |
2617.1 |
|
4. |
2 μg |
3350.5 |
|
5. |
2.5 μg |
4047.1 |
|
6. |
3 μg |
4644.5 |
|
7. |
100μg
of Methanolic extract of gel |
1733.7 |
4.3 Method Validation:
1.From linearity studies it was found that Catechin showed good coefficient of correlation in the
range 50- 300 ng/ band (r2= 0.998). The
developed method was validated as per the ICH guidelines.
2. The accuracy of method was defined by the
% recovery studies. Table No. 2 showed
the result of % recovery studies. From this the method was found to be
accurate.
Table
No: 2 Results of Accuracy
|
Sample Injected |
Obtained AUC |
Expected AUC |
Percent recovery (%) |
|
300 μg of methanol extract of gel |
1402.26 (A) |
|
|
|
0.5 μg of Catechin |
1201.2 (B) |
|
|
|
300 μg of methanol extract of gel + 0.5 μg of Catechin |
2578.1 |
2603.46 (A+B) |
99.02 % |
|
1 μg of Catechin |
2104.6 (C) |
|
|
|
300 μg of methanol extract of gel + 1 μg of Catechin |
3528.1 |
3506.86 (A+C) |
100.60% |
|
1.5 μg of Caffeine |
3152.8 (D) |
|
|
|
300 μg of methanol extract of gel +1.5 μg of Catechin |
4600.2 |
4555.06 (A+D) |
100.99% |
3.The low % RSD value indicate the suitability of the method.% RSD was found to
be less than 2 % from repeatability studies, which proves the method was
precise.
Table 3: Repeatability studies
of Catechin
|
Sr. No. |
Peak area for 0.5 μg |
Peak area 1.5 μg |
Peak area for 3 μg |
|
1. |
1343.3 |
2426.7 |
4463.8 |
|
2. |
1340.6 |
2430.7 |
4492.3 |
|
3. |
1330.5 |
2467.9 |
4497.9 |
|
4. |
1342.6 |
2430.0 |
4507.2 |
|
5. |
1350.5 |
2456.2 |
4536.5 |
|
Mean |
1337.8 |
2442.3 |
4499.54 |
|
S.D. |
7.198 |
18.559 |
26.254 |
|
% RSD |
0.536 |
0.759 |
0.583 |
4. The limit of
detection for Catechin was found to be 20 ngm and limit of quantitaion for catechin was found to be 50 ngm
5. The method was found
to be robust and the results were given in the table no.4
Table
No: 4 Result of Robustness
|
% Change in mobile phase |
Rf |
Peak area |
|
60:60:5:10 |
0.28 |
3010.5 |
|
58:62:6:9 |
0.27 |
3125.1 |
|
59.5:60.1:9:10.1 |
0.28 |
3097.2 |
6. The developed
method was used to determine the concentration of Catechin
in Gel. In the % content of catechin in the Gel was
found to be 7.6%
Table
No:5 Results of Method validation
|
Sr.
No. |
Parameters
For Method Validation |
Result
Values |
|
1. |
Precision
(Repeatability) |
0.0564 |
|
2. |
Accuracy (% Recovery) |
100.3
% |
|
3. |
Coefficient
Of Correlation |
0.998 |
|
4. |
Limit
of Detection |
20 ngm |
|
5. |
Limit of
Quantitation |
50ngm |
|
6. |
Robustness |
No
Significant change in peak area and Rf |
5.
CONCLUSION:
The new HPTLC method was
developed for Catechin and proposed method was
validated as per ICH guidelines. The % RSD and standard deviation calculated
for the method were low, indicating the high degree of precision of the method.
The result of the recovery studies indicating the high degree of accuracy of
the developed method. Hence, it can be concluded that the developed method can
be used for the estimation of Catechin from herbal
formulations.
6. REFERENCES:
1) Kokate C. K. Purohit A. P., Gokhale S. B.,
Pharmacognosy , 21st edition, Nirali prakashan , Pune, pp 121, 2002
2) T.J Vidya,Dr.Kala Suhas Kulkarni “beneficial Effect Of Green Tea With Special Reference To Neuropathy: Review and PilotTrial” Ancient science of life Vol:XXII(I)
July/2002
3) Bell, S. J. and Goodrick, G. K. A functional food product for the management of weight. Crit, Rev. Journal of Food Science
Nutrition,42(2),163(2002)
4) Loest, H. B., Noh, S. K.
N. S. and koo, S. I. Green Tea extract inhibits the
lymphatic absorption of cholesterol and alpha – tocopherol
in ovari ectomized rats,
Journal of Nutrition.132 (6),1282(2002)
5) Satoh,K.,Sakamoto,Y.,Ogata,A.,Nagai,F.,Mikuriya,H,Numazawa,M.,Yamada,K.ad
Aoki,N.Inhibition of aromatase
activity of Green Tea extract catechins and their endocronological effects of oral administration in rats.
Journal of Food chemistry and Toxology.40(7),925(2002)
6) John, T. J. and Mukundan , P. Antiviral property of tea .Current Science
47,159(1978).
7) Hsu,S.D.,Singh,B.B.,Lewis,J.B.,Borke,J.L.Dickinson,D.P.,Drake,L.,Caughman,G.B.and
Schuster, G. S. Chemoprevention of oral cancer by green tea.Gen.Dent.50(2),140(2002)
8) Toda, M., Okubo,
S., Ohnishi, R. and Shimamura, T. Antibacterial and
bactericidal activities of Japnese Green Tea. Nippon Saikingaku Zasshi(Tokyo)14,669(1989)
9) Fourneau, C., Laurens, A., Hocquemiller, R. and Cave, A. Radical scavenging evaluation
of Green Tea extracts .Phutytherapy res.10,529(1996)
10) Das, M., Vedasiromoni, J. R., Chauhan, S.
P. S. and Ganguly, D.K .effect of green tea extract
on rat diaphragm. Journal of Ethanopharmacology 57,197(1997)
11) Kokate C. K. Purohit A. P., Gokhale S. B.,
Pharmacognosy , 21st edition, Nirali prakashan ,Pune,pp 265,2002
12) Kokate C. K. Purohit A. P., Gokhale S. B.,
Pharmacognosy , 21st edition, Nirali prakashan , Pune, pp 600, 2002
13)
Singh A. P. ‘Ayurveda and Drug
standardization’, www.siu.edu/~ebl/leaflets/standards.html-42k.
14) Paridhavi M.,
Agarwal S.S., 55th Indian Pharmaceutical Congress
2003, Abstract no.34, pp 55.
Received on 10.05.2011 Accepted on 22.05.2011
©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Res. J. Topical and Cosmetic Sci. 2(1): Jan. –June 2011
page 25-29